At a glance, R2 needs to be 820R (820 Ohms). It currently appears to be 820K Ohms (820,000 Ohms), which would definitely cause your issue.
Additionally, for the Status LED, use the non-white outer pad for the Cathode. The white pad is only for bi-color LEDs to indicate Off status. The center pad is your Anode. This is what is making you think the pedal is On when it is actually Off.
Also looking at C1 you are using a 10n instead of a 100n which will cut a lot of your Bass content.